
3rd Oct, 2008, the cultural Capital of India proved on this date that
“WHAT INDIA THINKS TODAY, BENGAL WILL THINK AFTER 20 YEARS”
On this date, West Bengal said “TA TA” to Tatas for their NANO car project thereby distancing themselves from industrialization and growth, by another 20 years.
On this date, the dream of becoming Chief Minister of the State and defeating the Left, said “TA TA” to the Trinamool leader, Mamata.
On this date, the Buddhadeb proved that he has said “TA TA” to his leadership skills and political intellect, forever.
The State Politics,
National Politics and the International Politics made its affect felt and the world’s first cheapest car of Indian origin, left its first home before it was even born. Let us try to understand, the dynamics which lead to this historic show and players of this big game.
The cast consists of

Ratan Tata – The blind man.
Buddhadeb – The feeble King.
Karat – The Clown in disguise.
Mamata – The stubborn Traitor.
Manmohan – The Puppet King.
The Story unfolds…
The people of West Bengal, I doubt, would have ever known Ratan Tata, till he became blind. One fine day he had a dream of making World’s cheapest car “NANO” when he saw a family driving on a scooter. He went on realizing his dream and selected the kingdom of West Bengal as birthplace of Nano. It’s just a coincidence; Bengali meaning for “NA”, in English is “NO”. Till this time Ratan Tata was able to see but then a blindness of a special kind enveloped him. He was not able to see through the promises made to him. He started believing in the Indian political system which back stabbed him when he needed its help, the most. He was not able to see through the decision of selecting Singur, for his Nano’s birthplace, which was a Trinamool bastion. He was not able to see through the incompetence of the feeble king – Buddhadeb’s ability to control the opposition.
Blindness gripped him so much that he was compelled to say “I still have a great deal of respect for the leadership of Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee”; on the day he announced his withdrawal from Singur.

The chief Minister,
Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, came to power with a vision of giving West Bengal a push towards Industrialization. He never knew, at that time, that if he has to realize his vision, he has to be politically correct in dealing with his own party and the opposition party. When I say, “Politically Correct”, I mean the typical Indian style of governing a state, using the intelligence agencies to dig into political rivals, using the police machinery to silent the yelling rivals, seducing the foes to become friends by giving them suitcases. But then a Gentleman chief minister like Buddhadeb cannot be “Politically Correct”.
But when he back tracked on his statement on “Bandhs”, but when his government land acquisition process made the farmers berserk, but when his state police undermined the Singur Agitation and opened fire, when he did not learnt from the Nandigram fiasco and allowed Mamata to block National Highway for weeks, was he acting in the right spirit of a Gentleman chief minister. He was only showing his trait of a feeble and weak leader who can only announce revised compensations and pray to the Tata’s to not to go back.
A traitor is that person who goes against the state and shakes hand with the Nation’s enemy. Neah!
Mamata Bannerjee cannot be a traitor.
Can taking help from the Maoists of the state is not a trait of a traitor? Can blocking a national highway for weeks together thereby trying to choke the lifeline of the state, is an act of a patriot? Well, I left it to my readers to decide it.
First chemical hub at
Nandigram, then Tata’s Small car project in
Singur, next in pipeline is Reliance Fresh – how can a responsible politician have this agenda? Well, if the politician had a vengeance that I will go against any thing which the ruling party is doing, then this agenda holds good. No matters the state plunges into darkness of non-industrialization, no matters how many people loose jobs, no matter how many good opportunities are lost for growth, Mamata will not budge. A opposition party leader who not only work against the ruling party but also against the state and its people, does not have a sense of what is good for her own party as well as her own political career, can only deserve to be an arrogant traitor.
Now to conclude, we will read the clown and puppet story. There was an Indian puppet king who always did what the Italian Queen will say. He had the support of an Indian or Chinese or Russian – I am not sure. One day the Puppet king decided that he will no longer be puppet and went ahead to shake hands with Uncle Sam for Kingdom’s nuclear deal. The left, under leadership of Prakash Karat, gave some restless nights for
Manmohan Singh, our King. The king went on to strike the deal, without the support of left, endangering his own government, which made Prakash Karat a clown in distress. Then, came the payback time,
Prakash Karat’s decision to withdraw support from ruling party over the Nuke deal, was returned back to him. Congress told straightway that they cannot do much for the Singur issue rather the state should deal with it, on its own.
Its time for Bengal to think, what they want to be “ An intellectual forward looking Indian state or irrational dead state whose disgruntled youths will add to the numbers, of the Maoists, in future.”
Also ReadThe Left - West Bengal.